Hire Copywriters Well: You’re Not the Best Judge of the Work
In a study published in 2016, the Stanford organisational behaviour researcher Justin Berg asked 339 circus professionals to watch videos of new acts and predict which ones audiences would love. He then checked their guesses against the reactions of more than 13,000 audience members. The people who decide what gets staged, the managers, were the weakest judges in the room. The best were peers who make work of their own.
I think about that study whenever someone sets out to hire copywriters. Most hiring processes put the final call with exactly the person the research says is least equipped to make it.
Table of Contents
The people who approve ideas are bad at spotting the new ones
Berg’s study, published in Administrative Science Quarterly, found that creators were more accurate than managers when forecasting the success of other people’s novel ideas. The managers’ problem was not that they liked bad work. It was that they undervalued the unusual. According to Stanford’s write-up of the research, creators saw value in novel ideas that managers marked down, and managers who also had creative duties of their own did better than pure managers.
The creators were not perfect either. They overrated their own acts. A later set of five experiments by Berg found that people tend to under-rank their own highest-potential idea, so the one they think is second best often turns out to be the best. Nobody, in other words, is a reliable judge of their own work. The most reliable judge is someone who does the work and has no stake in this particular piece.
Circus is not advertising, and I would not stretch a single field study too far. But the pattern is familiar to anyone who has watched a portfolio review: the person holding the budget gravitates to the safe, recognisable piece, and the strange, brilliant one gets a polite nod.
Why the safe copywriter for hire looks so attractive
There is a reason for that nod, and it is not bad taste. In a 2011 paper titled “The Bias Against Creativity”, Jennifer Mueller, Shimul Melwani and Jack Goncalo ran two experiments with more than 200 people. When participants were made to feel uncertain, they were more likely to associate words like “creative” and “original” with words like “poison” and “agony”, and they were more likely to reject an objectively novel product idea. As the Association for Psychological Science summarised it, “creative ideas are rejected all the time.”
The study is older than I would normally lean on, and it was run in a lab rather than a marketing department. Still, think about the conditions under which most companies look for a copywriter for hire: a launch date, a nervous stakeholder, a budget that has to be justified. That is uncertainty by design. It is the exact state in which, according to this research, we stop wanting the original thing we said we wanted in the brief.
Marketers are close to a coin toss on what works
If the bias were offset by accurate instincts about what performs, it would matter less. The evidence suggests it isn’t. Nicole Hartnett and Rachel Kennedy of the Ehrenberg-Bass Institute surveyed about 700 marketers, creatives and insight staff at a global consumer goods company and its agencies, asking them to predict which ads would be more effective at driving sales. Across roughly 2,200 predictions, 51% were correct and 49% were wrong. Tenure and responsibility for approving ads made no difference to accuracy.
That is one company, and the published summary is short. But it is a sobering number from a serious research group, and it should make anyone hiring creative talent humbler about relying on the feeling a piece of work gives them in a meeting.
How to hire copywriters when your gut is unreliable
The broader research on hiring points the same way. A major 2022 re-analysis of selection methods by Paul Sackett and colleagues in the Journal of Applied Psychology found that structured interviews had the highest mean validity (.42) for predicting job performance, ahead of job knowledge tests (.40) and work sample tests (.33). This is research across jobs in general, not creative roles specifically. Its lesson is about structure: deciding in advance what good looks like, and judging everyone against it, beats improvising.
Put the four bodies of evidence together and my view is this. If you want to hire copywriters who will do original work, take some of the judgement out of your own hands. Write down, before you look at a single portfolio, what the brief actually needs the writer to solve. Assess against that, not against how comfortable a sample makes you feel. And bring in someone who writes, or has written, for a living, and who has no attachment to the outcome. Berg’s research suggests that is the person most likely to spot the idea you would otherwise pass over.
None of this means managers should hand over the decision. It means the decision gets better when the people who understand the craft shape the shortlist, and the people who understand the business make the final call against a clear brief.
Judgement is the scarce part
This is the logic behind how we work at Copywriter Collective. A client briefs us, and we recommend the senior copywriter or creative director from our personally vetted roster who is matched to that brief. It is not a database to scroll through, because scrolling is exactly where the bias against the unfamiliar does its quiet work. Content is easy to find. The judgement to recognise the original thinker, before the market proves them right, is the thing worth paying for.
Sources
- Justin Berg, “Balancing on the Creative High-Wire: Forecasting the Success of Novel Ideas in Organizations”, Administrative Science Quarterly (abstract via Wharton Mack Institute), 2016
- Louise Lee, “Managers Are Not Always the Best Judge of Creative Ideas”, Stanford Graduate School of Business, 2016
- Justin M. Berg, “When Silver Is Gold: Forecasting the Potential Creativity of Initial Ideas”, Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 2019
- “Why No One Really Wants Creativity”, Cornell ILR School, 2011
- “Is There a Hidden Bias Against Creativity?”, Association for Psychological Science, 2011
- Nicole Hartnett and Rachel Kennedy (Ehrenberg-Bass Institute), “How’s Your Judgement?”, The ARF, 2017
- “Is Cognitive Ability the Best Predictor of Job Performance? New Research Says It’s Time to Think Again”, HumRRO, 2022 (on Sackett, Zhang, Berry & Lievens, Journal of Applied Psychology, 2022)
Jack Stafford is the founder of Copywriter Collective, a premium creative talent agency based in Amsterdam.


